PART 2
Her face went still.
It wasn’t fear. It was care, the kind a person takes carrying a full glass across a crowded room.
Dr. Dana Evans has been my doctor for eleven years. She has told me about my cholesterol, my left knee, and one suspicious mole.
I had never seen her go careful.
She set the wand down on the tray.
“Susan. Are you absolutely positive you’ve never had surgery?”
“Never. Jake was a C-section, in 1996. That’s all.”
“Then this isn’t Jake’s.”
She turned the monitor toward me.
I’m a retired school librarian. I spent thirty-one years teaching eleven-year-olds to check the source.
I know a gray blur when I see one. I also know what it looks like when a book that should be on the shelf isn’t.
“Here is where a uterus should be,” she said, tracing the air. “I don’t see one.”
The paper crackled under me.
“There are two bright points here. Surgical clips. And this thin, bright line running beneath them. That isn’t tissue. It’s a synthetic mesh.”
“Mesh.”
“It’s used to hold things in place after a hysterectomy. It has been there a long time. It’s likely what you’ve been feeling.”
“I would know.”
“You’d think so.”
I kept looking at the place where I was missing.
“In 2008 I was in the hospital for five days,” I said. “They pumped my stomach.”
“A stomach pump doesn’t do this.”
“Michael said—”
“I’m sure he did.”
It was the most careful sentence I have ever heard.
“I’m a doctor, not a detective,” Dana said. “I won’t guess at anyone’s reasons.
But I’d like you to go home and ask your husband what really happened to you in 2008.”
Then, softer: “Don’t ask it angry. Ask it like you’re collecting evidence.”
I sat in the parking garage for twenty minutes with both hands on the wheel.
I didn’t cry.
I did my crying in 2008. It didn’t help.
I thought about the ache I’d called age, then scar tissue, then the price of being a woman.
I thought about a hospital bed and a burning throat.
And Michael’s hand around mine.
The pain is just from them pumping your stomach.
Then I thought about the hallway.
Eighteen years of Michael flattening himself against the wall so our sleeves wouldn’t touch.
I had always believed I was being punished.
I had never once asked what for.
The Release of Information office at Lakeview Regional is in the basement, past the gift shop and a vending machine that eats dollars.
A clerk named Rhonda took my license and Dana’s signed request. She typed for a long time.
“Twelve pages,” she said. “Oh. There’s a flag on the rest. ‘Research file. IRB hold.’ Risk Management has to release that.”
“I’ll take what you have.”
“Mrs. Hartley, I’m not sure—”
“They’re my pages.”
She looked at the door. She slid them into a folder.
I read them in my car with the dome light on.
OPERATIVE REPORT. April 17, 2008. Procedure: Total abdominal hysterectomy with sacrocolpopexy, CoreSupport polymer mesh, per HALO-2 protocol. Surgeon and Principal Investigator: Walter R. Strand, MD.
Indication: Pelvic organ pathology; patient desires definitive management.
Behind it sat a consent form.
I, Susan M. Hartley, understand and consent to the above procedure. I decline notification of my spouse. Signed: April 17, 4:10 p.m.
The signature was mine, almost.
I cross my t’s with one long flat bar. I’ve done it since library school.
The t in “Hartley” on that page had no bar at all. It was a stick, leaning right.
The discharge summary said gastric lavage, observation. It didn’t mention surgery.
But the ICU flow sheet was stapled underneath.
April 16, 11:40 p.m. Admitted, obtunded. Intubated for airway protection. April 18, 6:00 a.m. Extubated.
At 4:10 on the afternoon of the seventeenth, I had a tube down my throat.
Somebody had signed my name for me.
Michael was at his workbench in the garage, sharpening a mower blade, with the radio low.
He’s sixty-seven. He was a civil engineer for thirty-eight years. He measures things.
“Michael. Come inside.”
He came. He wiped his hands on a rag, because he always does.
At the kitchen table, I laid the operative report in front of him.
He read the first line.
He read it with the rag still in his fist.
His face went gray from the top down, like a window shade.
“Where did you get that?”
“Lakeview. Is it true?”
“Susan—”
“Michael.”
He sat down as if his knees had been cut.
“Yes,” he said.
I had expected a fight. I hadn’t expected how quiet it would be.
“Why did you tell me it was my stomach?”
“Because I thought you wanted it kept from me.”
“Wanted it—”
“You asked for it, Susan.”
He got up and went to the study. I heard the bottom drawer of his desk, the one he never lets me touch.
He came back with a thin yellow folder and set it on the table.
“March of 2009. A letter came for you from a company called Halcyon Surgical. ‘Important Patient Safety Notice.’ You were at school. I opened it.”
He slid it across.
Participants in Study HALO-2 who received the CoreSupport device should contact the Study Office.
“I’d never heard of any study,” he said. “I called the hospital. A woman in Medical Records faxed me this.”
A page.
The same consent form.
I decline notification of my spouse.
“Do you know what I thought?” His voice shook. “It was a year after I found out about him. I thought, she changed her body without telling me. So there’d never be a child. So nothing would tie her to anything. I thought you’d done it while I was down in the cafeteria drinking bad coffee.”
“Michael.”
“I couldn’t ask. If I asked, you might lie again. I couldn’t live through the answer.”
I put my hand flat on the table.
“I never signed it.”
He looked at me.
“I was on a ventilator at 4:10 p.m. on the seventeenth. Look at the flow sheet.”
He read it.
He read it again.
I watched eighteen years come apart behind his eyes.
“They told me stomach pump,” he whispered. “I sat in that hallway three nights. They never told me you were in surgery.”
“No.”
“I didn’t know about a ventilator.”
“No.”
He put his fist against his mouth.
“I’ve been punishing you for something you didn’t do.”
“And I’ve been punishing myself for something I did,” I said. “That one is mine, and I won’t pretend it isn’t. But this isn’t.”
I tapped the fax.
“Who is Brenda?”
He frowned. “What?”
“Here, at the bottom. Initials. B.K., Study Coordinator.”
“The woman who answered the phone. Brenda. She said everything was in order.” He swallowed. “Then a lawyer called. A Mr. Dunmore, for the hospital. He said if I contacted the manufacturer again, they’d have to disclose your psychiatric admission, to your employer and the school board. I was afraid for you. I stopped.”
I looked at my husband, who had spent eighteen years frightened on my behalf, and who had never once told me.
I photographed every page with the lamp slanted so nothing glared. I emailed them to an account I made on the spot.
Michael watched me do it.
“We have to be careful,” I said.
“I know.”
“Boring. Extraordinarily boring.”
For the first time in eighteen years, he almost smiled.
At 7:02 the next morning, the landline rang.
We still have a landline. It’s for the pharmacy and wrong numbers.
I pressed record.
“Susan Hartley.” A warm baritone, unhurried. “Walter Strand. It’s been a long time.”
I said nothing.
“Emeritus now. Eleven years out of the operating room, and they still put my name on a lecture.” A small, sorry chuckle. “My records office tells me you stopped by yesterday. I hope nothing’s wrong.”
“Thank you for calling.”
“Of course. Why don’t you and Michael come for coffee Saturday? Carol and I would love it. I’ll walk you through the chart myself. I remember that spring. You were so brave.”
“Brave.”
“You asked me to keep it from Michael, remember? You cried. I’ve never forgotten it.”
Across the kitchen, Michael’s coffee cup stopped halfway to his mouth.
“I’d hate for anyone to go digging, Susan. It’s a two-way street. Your admission that April was a psychiatric one. If this ever reached discovery, the details would be public. Jake’s thirty. He works for the state. Imagine him reading that in a file.”
He said our son’s name like a hand laid on a shoulder.
“I’ll think about it,” I said.
“Take your time. But I’d come before the weekend.”
He hung up first.
I played it back twice.
He had never said which spring.
At 4:40 that afternoon, I went out to the mailbox.
There was no stamp on it.
Inside was a plain envelope. In it, a photocopy of a yellow legal pad.
My name, in blue ballpoint.
Susan M. Hartley. Susan M. Hartley. Susan M. Hartley.
Forty times, down the page.
The first was clumsy. By the twentieth, it leaned. By the fortieth, the t had lost its bar and the loop on the H had my exact hesitation.
Pinned to the corner was a yellow sticky note, in a small, upright hand.
Don’t call Walter. Alder Street, 7 p.m. Bring your husband. Come in a different car. —C. Strand
I turned it over.
Carol Strand was Walter’s wife.
(This is a work of fiction.)
PART 3
Alder Street is a block of shuttered storefronts behind the old courthouse.
At 6:58, a gray Buick sat under the one working streetlight with its engine off.
We took Michael’s truck, because I’d asked him to borrow his brother’s. Not a bad idea for a woman who’d just learned what it meant to be followed.
A woman got out of the Buick.
She was sixty-nine, tall and straight, with short silver hair and a navy raincoat buttoned wrong, one hole off. She had a red accordion folder pressed against her chest.
She stopped three feet from me.
“Mrs. Hartley. I’m Carol. I’m sorry for the sticky note. I didn’t know another way.”
“You’re his wife.”
“For forty-one years.” She didn’t flinch. “I was the compliance director at Lakeview for twenty-seven. I can’t help taking things down. May I tell it in order?”
We sat in the back of her car, with the dome light off and the folder across all three of our laps.
She spoke the way a woman reads minutes at a church board.
“In 2005, Walter became a paid founder of a company called Halcyon Surgical. It had one product. CoreSupport. A mesh. The FDA wouldn’t approve it without a clinical trial, a hundred women with two years of follow-up.”
“HALO-2.”
“He could never recruit. Women read the consent, asked questions, and went home. He had a hospital full of patients who’d never be asked.”
I felt Michael go very still beside me.
“Fourteen women,” Carol said. “Between 2006 and 2012. Every one came through the ER after an overdose, or a psychiatric hold, or a crisis that made her unreliable. Every one was unconscious or sedated when the paperwork was signed.”
“Signed by whom?”
She took out the legal pad.
“Brenda Kopec, his coordinator. She kept the practice sheets in a drawer. I found them in 2012.”
The same forty signatures. The same name.
On the next page, another woman’s name. Then another.
Fourteen names.
“Halcyon paid the Strand Women’s Research Fund eighty-five thousand dollars per implant,” Carol said. “A million, one hundred ninety thousand. And if the FDA cleared the device, Walter’s shares were worth nine million.”
I looked at the list.
Mine was the ninth.
“He chose us because we wouldn’t be believed,” I said.
“He chose you because you had a note in your chart that said ‘depression with suicidal ideation,’” Carol said gently. “And because the world already had a story about women like that.”
Layer one had been my body.
Layer two was a business, built on women nobody would listen to.
“There’s one more thing,” she said, and she didn’t open the next tab at once.
“Janice Rowe. She was number six. Thirty-eight. In 2013 the mesh eroded. She went to the ER five times in a year with pain. The notes say ‘anxiety, somatic.’”
“What happened?”
“Sepsis. She died on a Tuesday.”
I heard Michael draw a breath through his teeth.
“Patricia Kimball. Number eleven. Forty-four. Two years later. Same notes. Same words.”
She laid down two death certificates.
“Halcyon’s data package to the FDA lists no serious adverse events. Walter signed it. I found the real incident reports in his study.”
“Where’s the device now?”
“Recalled. Quietly. In 2017.” Her mouth thinned. “I told the hospital, Mrs. Hartley. In April of 2012, I wrote a memo about a study consent that didn’t look right. Walter found it on the kitchen counter that night. He read it twice and said, ‘Carol, you’ve been tired. You should retire for your health.’”
“Did you?”
“I was fifty-five. I did.” She almost laughed. “I made coffee. I said all right. And then I made a copy of everything I’d ever touched, and I put it in a freezer in the church basement, in a box marked Christmas.”
“Why now?”
“Because I needed a living woman who could sit in a witness chair,” she said. “Competent, credible, with a spouse who kept the fax. Janice can’t. Patricia can’t. Nine of the others are afraid of their own families, and one is in a nursing home. When the release office flagged your request, I got an alert. I’ve been waiting eleven years for that email.”
Michael put his forehead against the front seat.
He cried the way men do who haven’t in a long time. No sound, only shoulders.
“I should have asked,” he said.
“So should I,” I said. “We’ll ask now.”
I thought about four things I had called my marriage.
The guest room I’d moved into and never left.
The hallway wall.
The pain is just from them pumping your stomach.
The day Jake, twelve and watching from the stairs, asked why Dad never sat next to me on the sofa.
I had called every one of them punishment.
They were all the same lie, told in two directions.
We drove to Bernadette Okoye’s house at nine.
She’s a medical-malpractice attorney in her sixties, with a gray braid and sneakers under her suit. She answered the door in a bathrobe with a pencil through her hair.
“Don’t tell me a single thing yet,” she said. “Put the kettle on, Michael. You know where I keep it.”
He did, because she’d been his lawyer for the house.
She read for two hours.
At midnight she called a document examiner named Frank Delacroix, who picked up on the first ring and said, “If it’s what I think it is, I’ll drive.”
By one a.m., we had it on the back of a legal pad.
Legal. A sworn complaint to the FDA’s Office of Criminal Investigations, with Carol’s practice sheets, the flow sheet, and the fax. A civil action would follow. Frank would compare the signatures by Monday.
Financial. A forensic accountant would trace the Research Fund. Halcyon’s shareholders had a right to know.
The third column, Bernadette left blank.
“Walter wins by being the first voice in the room,” she said. “Consent is his whole persona. Who better to say a patient agreed?”
“So the people who decide hear it first,” I said. “With paper.”
“No adjectives.”
By Tuesday morning, Harriet Pell, the retired judge who chairs the hospital board, had signed for a sealed courier packet.
So had the chief medical officer.
Walter Strand made his move on Wednesday.
At 9 a.m., a letter arrived from Bernadette’s counterpart, a Mr. Dunmore.
On behalf of Dr. Strand, we write to offer Mrs. Hartley $250,000 and a mutual non-disclosure agreement. The offer expires Friday at 5 p.m.
Michael read it twice.
“Two hundred fifty thousand dollars,” he said. “For my wife’s uterus.”
“Don’t,” I said. “Don’t say it that way.”
“Susan—”
“I’d like it in the file.”
I forwarded it to Bernadette.
She wrote back one word.
Exhibit.
At 3 p.m. a post appeared on the Maple Heights Neighbors page, from an account with a stock photo of a daisy.
Did you know that your neighbor Susan Hartley, a “beloved” retired librarian, had an affair and attempted suicide in 2008? She has been making ugly accusations against a well-respected physician. Ask yourself why.
Nineteen comments in the first hour.
Most were kind.
A few weren’t.
Jake called at 4:12. He’d driven forty minutes from the state office with the phone in his hand.
“Mom. I saw it.”
“I know.”
“I don’t care. Do you hear me? I don’t care about any of it.” His voice cracked. “I just want to hear it from you. All of it.”
“Can you come this evening?”
“I’m already in the car.”
He sat on my back porch until two in the morning.
I told him everything.
The affair. The pills. The hospital. The mesh.
He didn’t say anything for a long time.
Then he took my hand and said, “Mom, I knew something was wrong in that house since I was twelve. I thought it was my fault.”
“It was never yours.”
“I’m here to stay,” he said.
Thursday, 7:52 a.m.
The Lakeview Regional auditorium is a tiered room with blue carpet, a stage, and a banner that hangs from the ceiling.
THE WALTER R. STRAND ANNUAL LECTURE ON INFORMED CONSENT. “Consent Is the Oldest Promise in Medicine.”
Three hundred seats. Nearly all of them filled with residents in scrubs, nurses with coffee, and a long row of board members in good wool.
I walked in through the side door with Michael on my left and Jake on my right.
Carol was beside me in the navy raincoat, buttoned correctly now.
Bernadette had her briefcase. Frank Delacroix carried a flat black case. Beside Harriet Pell in the front row sat a woman in a gray jacket with a badge clipped to her belt and a folder in her lap.
Dana Evans stood at the back wall in her white coat, arms folded.
On the stage, at a podium of dark wood, stood Walter Strand.
Seventy-one. White hair. A bow tie. A voice that had been reassuring rooms for forty years.
“Consent,” he said, “is not a form. It is a conversation.”
He looked up.
He saw me.
Then he saw who was sitting beside me.
(This is a work of fiction.)
ENDING
Walter Strand didn’t stop talking.
That was his gift. Forty years of lectures had taught him to keep the sentence moving.
“—and we owe our patients the dignity of being heard.”
He smiled straight at me.
“I see we have a guest. Mrs. Susan Hartley, ladies and gentlemen. A former patient of mine, and a very brave woman.”
Three hundred heads turned.
“Dr. Strand,” I said. I hadn’t planned to speak. I stood, in my good gray coat, with a folder against my chest. “May I ask a question about informed consent?”
“I’m afraid this is a scheduled lecture—”
“Let her ask,” said Harriet Pell.
She’s seventy-four, a retired judge, with white hair and a voice that has never needed raising. When she says three words, people stop moving.
Walter stopped.
“Of course,” he said. Warm. Easy. “Questions are welcome.”
Bernadette plugged a laptop into the cable meant for his slides.
The screen behind him changed.
A consent form.
I, Susan M. Hartley, consent. I decline notification of my spouse. Signed April 17, 4:10 p.m.
“That’s a patient record,” Walter said. “That’s confidential.”
“It’s mine,” I said.
Next slide.
ICU FLOW SHEET. April 16, 11:40 p.m. Admitted, obtunded. Intubated. April 18, 6:00 a.m. Extubated.
“At 4:10 p.m. on April seventeenth, I was on a ventilator,” I said. “I’d like to know how I signed.”
A murmur rolled across the room.
“Mrs. Hartley, you were lucid in the ICU, and you were upset. People don’t remember.”
“I do.”
“It was eighteen years ago. A chart is a chart.”
“Then let’s look at some more,” said Frank Delacroix.
He stepped onto the stage with the flat case and opened it.
He’s seventy, a retired forensic examiner with a mustache gone gray in the middle and a magnifier on a cord. He spoke without a single adjective.
“I compared the signature on this consent form to forty known samples of Mrs. Hartley’s handwriting. I also compared it to this.”
Carol’s legal pad filled the screen.
Susan M. Hartley. Forty times. Each a little closer.
“Same pen. Same pad. Same hand,” Frank said. “This isn’t hers. It was written by the study coordinator, who practiced.”
Walter’s smile moved.
“That’s Brenda’s,” he said, too quickly. “An unfortunate clerical practice. I had no idea.”
“I thought you might say that.”
Carol stood.
She’d been sitting so still beside me that nobody had noticed her.
“Hello, Walter.”
He stared at her.
“Carol. You shouldn’t be here.”
“I’ve sat in the front row of every one of these for forty-one years,” she said. “I’d like to sit in this one.”
She took a small speaker from her handbag and pressed play.
Walter’s own voice filled the auditorium, low and easy, from a kitchen eleven years ago.
“Nobody believes the ones from the psych ward, Carol. That’s not a risk. That’s the design.”
Nobody moved.
“That’s out of context,” Walter said.
“Please,” said Carol. “Tell us the context.”
He had no answer.
“I wrote you a memo in 2012,” she said. “It was left on the counter. You said I’d retire for my health. I did. I kept a copy of everything.”
“Carol—”
“Two women died, Walter.”
She laid two death certificates on the lectern.
“Janice Rowe. Thirty-eight. Patricia Kimball. Forty-four. They were told their pain was in their heads.”
In the fourth row, a woman in her thirties put her hand over her mouth.
“That’s my mother,” she said.
She stood.
She said it again, steadier. “Janice Rowe was my mother.”
Then another woman, in a red wool coat, got to her feet.
“Number three,” she said. “April 2007.”
Another.
“Number eight.”
One at a time, in a room full of doctors, they said their numbers.
Seven of them.
They didn’t shout.
Michael stood last.
He walked into the aisle in the gray suit he wore to funerals.
“I’m Michael Hartley,” he said. “I sat in that hallway for three nights while my wife was operated on. I was told it was a stomach pump. When I learned the truth, a lawyer threatened to release her psychiatric records if I spoke.”
His voice cracked and held.
“I let myself be afraid for eighteen years. I’m sorry, Susan.”
I didn’t say anything.
I put my hand on his arm.
It wasn’t forgiveness yet.
It was a hand.
Walter tried one more time.
I watched him reach for it. The voice rose in him the way it always did, warm and reasonable and wounded.
“Everyone. Please. This is a woman with a documented psychiatric history, and these people are being used—”
“Walter,” said Harriet Pell.
“Judge Pell, twenty-six years—”
“The board met at seven this morning.”
She stood. She held up a single sheet.
“Effective immediately, Dr. Strand’s emeritus status and clinical privileges are revoked. Every consent bearing his countersignature in connection with HALO-2 is void. His name is removed from this lecture, from the Women’s Pavilion, and from the Research Fund.”
She laid the page on the lectern.
“We’d like your resignation from the Foundation. It requires two witnesses to your signature.”
Walter looked at the page.
He picked up his fountain pen.
For forty years, his power had been one sentence.
The patient consented.
It made a woman’s body a signature line. It made a chart into a story that everybody believed. It decided who was a patient and who was a risk.
He held the pen over the paper.
“Two witnesses,” said Harriet Pell. “Anyone in this room.”
Nobody moved.
Not the residents. Not the nurses. Not a single board member.
Three hundred people sat with their hands in their laps.
Nobody would witness his name.
His hand began to shake.
The pen touched the page, and the ink bled in a small, dark star.
He looked for someone to speak for him.
His lawyer, Mr. Dunmore, was already walking toward the exit.
The chief medical officer studied the floor.
Carol looked back at him, steadily.
I held his eyes.
He looked away first.
A woman in a gray jacket had been sitting in the front row since seven-forty.
She stood.
“Dr. Strand? Special Agent Lydia Banks, FDA Office of Criminal Investigations. I’d like a conversation. You’re not under arrest this morning. I’d call a lawyer who plans to stay.”
He took off his bow tie.
I don’t know why.
He folded it once and laid it on the lectern.
Then he walked down the steps and out through the side door, past the banner with his name on it.
Behind him, two workmen in blue shirts were already unscrewing the sign from the stage.
Three weeks later, a federal grand jury indicted Walter Strand on fraud against the United States, falsification of records, obstruction, and conspiracy.
He pleaded guilty in April.
Twelve years in federal prison. His license was revoked for life. Restitution topped six million dollars.
Halcyon Surgical’s executives pleaded to the false data package. The company was dissolved.
Brenda Kopec flew in from Tampa, cooperated for months, and took probation.
She wrote me a letter.
I answered with one line.
I hope the practice stopped when you did.
The two deaths were reopened.
A judge entered findings that both consents had been forged and that both women had died of complications of an unlawful implant.
Alicia Rowe sat in the front row beside me for the hearing, in her mother’s earrings.
When the judge said, “This court is sorry,” she didn’t cry.
She put her hand over her mouth, and her shoulders shook.
I sat beside her until she was done.
The settlement came in the fall.
I won’t say the number.
I put half into a scholarship at the nursing school, for patients’ advocates.
The plaque has a line on it.
FOR THE ONES WHO WERE NEVER ASKED.
Carol testified for two days.
She sat in the witness box in her buttoned-right raincoat and told a jury about a freezer in a church basement.
She filed for divorce on a Monday.
She works at a legal aid clinic now.
She didn’t ask me to forgive her for the eleven years. I told her I didn’t think I had to.
We have lunch on Wednesdays.
I forgave Michael slowly.
It took a year, and a counselor, and a great many Tuesday nights at our kitchen table.
I won’t say it didn’t.
I kept the guest room.
I like the light.
Forgiving a man and moving back into his bedroom are two different jobs.
I learned that this year.
The part I think about most is a small one.
One Sunday in March, I was reading on the sofa.
Michael stood in the doorway with two cups of tea.
He didn’t come any closer.
“May I?” he said.
I looked at the other end of the cushions.
I looked at him.
“Ask me in a minute,” I said.
He waited.
He waited for a very long minute, with the tea going cold.
Then I patted the cushion.
He sat down.
He didn’t flatten himself against the arm of the sofa. He didn’t hold his breath.
His hand was shaking, a little, when he handed me the cup.
I used to think strength was carrying my own punishment without a word.
I was wrong.
Strength, it turns out, asks for the chart, and reads every line of it out loud.
EPILOGUE
One year later.
April seventeenth.
Sunday afternoon, our living room.
Jake is thirty-one, and he’s brought a pie he baked himself. It sags in the middle.
Carol is in the good armchair, arguing with Bernadette about cinnamon. Dana Evans brought tulips.
I’m on the sofa.
Michael sits beside me, shoulder to shoulder, with a crossword and a pen.
Jake looks at the two of us from the doorway.
He doesn’t say a word.
He just takes out his phone and photographs the sofa.